| #1 | Monmouth IL | (9,2) | -1.273 | -0.637 |
| #2 | Illinois College | (9,2) | -1.313 | -0.676 |
| #3 | Lake Forest | (7,3) | -1.432 | -1.032 |
| #4 | Cornell IA | (6,4) | -1.302 | -1.102 |
| #5 | Chicago | (6,4) | -1.319 | -1.119 |
| #6 | Ripon | (5,5) | -1.357 | -1.357 |
| #7 | Knox | (3,7) | -1.374 | -1.774 |
| #8 | Grinnell | (2,8) | -1.344 | -1.944 |
| #9 | Beloit | (2,8) | -1.391 | -1.991 |
| #10 | Lawrence | (0,10) | -1.295 | -2.295 |